Book Review: Another by Paul Tremblay

In Another, Paul Tremblay offers a gripping, unsettling tale that explores themes of alienation, identity, and the supernatural through the lens of middle-grade horror. The novel follows Casey Wilson, a young boy struggling with the aftermath of a traumatic event known only as the "Zoom Incident." With tics worsening and a strained relationship with his peers, Casey feels more isolated than ever—until a mysterious boy named Morel shows up for an extended sleepover that quickly takes a dark turn.

Morel is unlike any friend Casey has known. His clay-like skin and silent demeanor set him apart, yet Casey's parents, once warm and supportive, begin to lavish attention on the strange newcomer, much to Casey's growing unease. As Morel's presence grows more dominant and unsettling, Casey begins to realize that his family is slipping further away, and he fears the boy might be replacing him altogether. The tension builds as Casey struggles to reclaim his place in a world that is increasingly indifferent to his existence.

While I’m not always drawn to Paul Tremblay's writing style, finding it occasionally meandering and distancing, there's no denying the suspense and psychological tension he creates here. Another is a compelling, though slightly disorienting, exploration of a boy grappling with the loss of control over his own life. The slow unraveling of reality keeps readers on edge, questioning the true nature of Morel and the motivations of those around Casey.

What makes Another particularly effective is its ability to balance the supernatural with the deeply personal. As Casey faces the challenge of asserting his identity, he is forced to confront his fears and insecurities in a world that feels increasingly hostile. The horror isn’t just in the otherworldly presence of Morel—it’s in the disconnection from his family, the erosion of trust, and the psychological torment of watching himself be replaced.

Though Tremblay’s style may not be universally appealing, Another shines as a thought-provoking middle-grade novel that taps into the universal fear of being forgotten, displaced, or misunderstood. It’s a dark, surreal journey into the complexities of self-worth, family, and the unsettling idea that sometimes the scariest monsters are the ones that come from within.

Overall, Another is a solid, if somewhat eerie, addition to the genre of supernatural middle-grade fiction. It’s an engaging, sometimes unnerving, exploration of growing up and finding your place in the world—especially when the world seems intent on replacing you. Tremblay fans and readers looking for a compelling, albeit slightly uncomfortable, coming-of-age story with a supernatural twist will find much to enjoy here.

---

This title will be released on July 22, 2025. Preorder it now!

(Links are for convenience. I am not an affiliate)