Valentine’s Day is here, bringing with it an inevitable deluge of romance across every genre imaginable. Chocolates, roses, and declarations of love have found their way into places they once dared not tread—like the dark, blood-soaked corridors of horror. For purists like myself, this can be a point of contention. Horror, after all, is meant to chill the spine and twist the mind, not warm the heart.
While it’s true that romance has existed in horror for centuries—think Dracula’s dark obsession with Mina Harker or the tragic love between Victor Frankenstein and Elizabeth—it was an accent, not the melody. These stories used romance to amplify horror, not to dilute it. Yet, as genre-blending becomes the trend, horror seems to be losing its edge, with romance taking center stage in ways that often feel forced or out of place.
The Role of Romance in Horror: When It Works
Romance can serve a purpose in horror, but it must be handled delicately. The contrast between love and terror can enhance the stakes, make characters more relatable, or create devastating emotional tension. For example:
Unhealthy Relationships as Horror: Movies like Midsommar use romance as a foundation to explore manipulation and emotional destruction. The romance isn’t the story; it’s the setup for something far darker.
Love as Motivation: Sometimes, a romantic bond is the only reason a character keeps fighting, as seen in The Fly, where Geena Davis’s character stays out of love, despite the grotesque transformation happening before her eyes.
Twisted Love Stories: Horror thrives on subverting expectations. A love story that turns obsessive, toxic, or downright monstrous (think Crimson Peak or The Shape of Water) can add layers to the narrative without overpowering the horror.
In these cases, romance doesn’t detract from the horror—it sharpens it. The problem arises when stories are mislabeled, promising horror but delivering a romance novel dressed in gothic attire.
Why Romance Can Feel Out of Place
Horror is about fear: fear of the unknown, the supernatural, or the monstrous. Introducing a romance-first storyline risks undermining that fear. Romantic subplots can:
Reduce Tension: A budding love story can take away from the suffocating atmosphere horror relies on. If characters are too focused on their love lives, it can feel disconnected from the stakes of the story.
Shift the Focus: When romance becomes the driving force, it pushes horror elements into the background. Suddenly, the terrifying monster or chilling mystery is just an obstacle to the lovers’ happy ending.
Alienate Purists: For those who turn to horror for its unflinching embrace of fear, gore, and psychological thrills, romance can feel like an unwelcome intrusion.
Let Horror Be Horror
This is not to say that romance has no place in genre fiction. But labeling something a “horror romance” can be misleading if the scales tip too far toward love. Horror should make your skin crawl and your heart race—not from a kiss in the rain, but from a figure lurking just out of sight.
Valentine’s Day is the perfect time to celebrate love in all its forms—whether it’s obsessive, doomed, or darkly twisted. But let’s not forget that horror’s strength lies in its ability to explore the bleak, the terrifying, and the grotesque. If romance enters the picture, it should be an accessory, not the centerpiece.
So this Valentine’s Day, I’ll be skipping the "horror romances" in favor of stories that keep my spine tingling and my heart pounding from terror—not love.
What about you? Do you think romance adds to or detracts from horror? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!
Comments